One stone hit a thousand waves. Since Gao Shun died in battle, I have heard criticisms as the author. It is no wonder that the characters in the Three Kingdoms in the minds of each reader are different. The author describes the people and things that belong to him, and arguments are inevitable. Here I would like to thank the opposition and agree readers who bravely express their views!

Let me tell you a few thoughts when I started writing and share with you.

700 soldiers from Gaoshun, Xinye City, started with 30,000 Cao soldiers:

1. The formation of military strategy has a process of accumulation. As described in the article, Gao Chong was not prepared enough when he sent troops to attack Jingzhou for the second time. At that time, Liu Biao was newly destroyed, and the Liu Bei group and Cai Mao group fought against the issue of inheritance rights. Although Liu Bei had just arrived in Jingzhou, he quickly used his identity as the emperor to fight with the Qing Dynasty scholars and officials, and took in Xu Jing, Xu Shao and others who were driven away by Gao Chong. This was a social force that cannot be ignored. Liu Bei, who regarded the Han family as the orthodox, and Gao Chong, who gradually abandoned the Han Dynasty, was like two irreconcilable oppositions. The contradiction would only intensify more and more. The contest between them and the people who depended on them was a war of faith, and neither Gao Chong nor Liu Bei could avoid it.

2. Therefore, after learning that Liu Bei returned to Xiangyang to seize power, Gao Chong and Zhou Yu both saw the key point. Their response was to quickly mobilize possible soldiers and encircle and annihilate the Guan Yu troops left by Jingling and Mianyang. This stage was the beginning of the Jingzhou war. Whether in terms of military strength, morale and the talents of the generals, Gao Chong's army had the upper hand. The result of the battle was that Guan Yu was defeated and died, and Liu Bei's attempt to seize power failed.

3. Liu Bei's escape. Liu Bei from the New Third Middle School was the main liaison figure who matched the three families against Jiangdong. In Jingzhou and Jiaozhou were attacked by Gao Chong, the only one Liu Zhang from Yizhou was the only one who could surrender was Liu Zhang from Yizhou. It is necessary to talk about the situation in Shu at that time. After Liu Yan's death, although his son Liu Zhang inherited the position of governor of the state, some powerful officials led by Zhao Wei, the great historian of the State of the State of Zhou did not buy it. In the sixth year of Jian'an (201 AD), Zhao Wei's troops besieged Chengdu, and Liu Zhang finally relied on it.

The help of the Dongzhou soldiers (a group of refugees formed by the people who moved into Shu in the Sili, Nanyang and Xiangyang areas) was to quell the rebellion. According to historical records, among Zhao Wei's subordinates, there was a general Gan Ning. The New Third Middle School did not make any comments because Gan Ning had appeared in advance. Therefore, although Liu Bei's strength was weaker at this time, it was also a considerable help for Liu Zhang, who had just ascended the throne. At least before Zhao Wei's power was pacified, Liu Zhang would not say anything he would not let Liu Bei enter Shu.

4. Liu Bei's escape route from Hanzhong. It is indeed quite difficult to enter Shuzhong from Hanzhong. When writing this paragraph, I also followed the Hanzhong map in detail. The Mikang Road and the Jinniu Road are both two traditional routes to Shu in history (the Yinping Road will not be mentioned). In the sixth year of Jian'an, the Tianshi Road Zhang Lu had just left the jurisdiction of Yizhou and was independent for less than a year. Before that, Liu Zhang sent the general Pang Yi to attack Hanzhong from Brazil, but suffered a crushing defeat. It was precisely because of this decisive battle that led to the temporary independence of Hanzhong. As a new regime, Zhang Lu's influence and strength were far less than that of the later period. Therefore,

After being attacked by Zhang Fei suddenly and rapidly, the Zhang Lu regime was a little beaten. In a hurry, Zhang Lu mistakenly thought that Liu Bei had the intention of plotting against Hanzhong, so he mobilized all the troops to gather in Nanzheng to fight Liu Bei. This was an act of no choice. At this time, Liu Bei used Sun Qian as a commander to make a statement and explained the meaning of passing through lobbying. For Zhang Lu, it seemed like a wolf who had just hunted food. Suddenly, he found a lion was also spying on him. He was frightened and sweated. When he finally found that the lion was just walking around, he breathed a sigh of relief.

5. The second stage of the Jingzhou Battle. Regarding the debate on the division of troops from all over the Xiangyang area, many readers say that with Zhou Yu and Xu Shu's talents, how could a first-class commander and first-class military advisor make such a low-level mistake? Although this statement makes some sense, it is still suspected of using historical figures to guess the New Third. In fact, after receiving the news of the riots of Jingxiang County, Gao Chong or Zhou Yu's first reaction was of course to send troops to quell the rebellion. At this time, if the counties were allowed to be left, it would be impossible to have a county chaos. Some readers said that refugees could be recruited to expand their troops. When the people were all hostile and uncooperative, could you recruit troops? Think about the process of Zhuge Liang sending troops to conquer the rebellion of the counties in Shu after Liu Bei's death in Baidi City in history, and everyone can know the reason.

During this period, Liu Bei had fled west. After Gao Chong used peaceful means to persuade Wenpin to surrender nearly 20,000 troops, he faced the task of suppressing the opposition forces in the county and resuming production as soon as possible. This task is actually not easier than fighting on the battlefield. After Liu Biao's inspiration to govern for more than ten years, the people in Jingzhou lived a very stable life. They supported the Liu Biao regime from the bottom of their hearts. Among them, there were not only Cai, Kuai, Yang, Xi and other big families, but also many ordinary people. Therefore, although Liu Cong's forces (headed by Cai Mao and Xiang Lang) withdrew from Xiangyang, their influence was everywhere. In this case, the people's hearts stood on the side of the enemy. We were open and secretly. Cai Mao and others could easily obtain important information from Gao Chong's newly occupied area, including the mobilization of troops, etc.

It is difficult for Gao Chong's side to obtain favorable intelligence from Wancheng, which Cao's army is closely guarding. At this time, the only source of intelligence, the exposure of the Yue-girl He Zong was fatal. To a certain extent, it was He Zong's death that made Xu Shu lose the ability to judge the facts for a while. Unfortunately, many readers focused too much on Zhou Yu and how talented and capable Xu Shu was, but did not think about how in different environments, people's abilities were sometimes maximized, but sometimes they could only play half or even half of them (attachment, I personally think that Zhou Yu's outstanding military command ability in the Battle of Chibi in historical facts has reached its peak, just as athletes' performances have peaks and troughs, and they cannot continue to do so).

6. Gao Chong’s Jiaozhou strategy. This is the place that many readers are most ill. Everyone thinks that Gao Chong should not fight south at this time, but should concentrate on managing Jingzhou. Here, I will re-interpret the Jiaozhou war actually happened before the Second Jingzhou Battle. At that time, Liu Biao, Liu Zhang and Shi Xie formed a group to fight against Gao Chong. If Gao Chong wants to break the encirclement, his first choice is to find a breakthrough. Jiaozhou is located in Lingnan and has inconvenient transportation. Shi Xie is also the weakest. The other two families cannot directly reinforce Shi Xie.

, taking Jiaozhou can firstly eliminate the hidden danger of being attacked in the rear, and secondly, it can hit the arrogance of the Qing Dynasty forces. Based on this meaning, Gao Feng ordered Pang Tong and Lu Fan to lead troops out of Lingqu. In the Jiaozhou strategy, the only problem is that Pang Tong's political ability is insufficient. Shi Xie is an old world. Compared with him, Pang Tong has outstanding military talents, but he is sinister than the people's hearts and is still a little worse than political repetition. In addition, Shi Shi operated in Jiaozhou for the sixth generation, and the people's hearts and foundations are quite deep. Therefore, Pang Tong's failure is both unexpected and reasonable.

7. Gao Chong went south. After Pang Tong was defeated, Gao Chong was shocked and rushed to Jingnan to seek medical treatment. This was actually the most worrying shortcoming of the author. As the commander of the first army, it was extremely unwise to leave at an important moment, but many readers also let go and criticize the author's fault. What is the reason? Pang Tong was Feng Chu, of course he could not die, so it was normal for Gao Chong to go to rescue him. In fact, it was not because Pang Tong was carefully established by Gao Chong to recruit people from Jingzhou. Even if Pang Tong was talented, Gao Chong could not go in person. It was precisely because of the turmoil in Jingxiang that he had just occupied that Gao Chong urgently needed to use Pang Tong's influence to differentiate the local opposition forces in Jingzhou, so he decided to go in person.

8. Evaluation of Zhou Yu's ability. Before Zhou Yu guarded Xiangyang, he had not actually commanded a major battle independently. Sun Ce and Gao Chong often appeared as a senior Mu Liao. The only two relatively independent battles were the retreat of Shentingling and the attempted military plan of Wucheng. These two battles were passive defensive for Zhou Yu, and they were all emergency responses after being under heavy pressure from Gao Chong. Afterwards, Zhou Yu led his troops alone to march for a long distance in the Jiangxia Battle. This was just a partial division, and Gao Chong was the one who was commanding behind him. Therefore, Zhou Yu of the New Third Middle School, I hope that his ability will improve step by step until he ushered in the glory of Chibi, rather than being invincible in the world as soon as he appeared and won every battle.

9. Why did Gao Shun appear in Xinye? He had to stick to the city. Regarding this point, I can only say that he was the most suitable candidate to take on this task. It is reflected in history and the Romance of the Book of Legends that Gao Shun's character is already quite distinct. I don't want to destroy the Qing copy of such a historical figure because of his own shabby pen. As mentioned above, Gao Shun's southern return was not due to his own wishes. On the contrary, although Lu Bu died at that time, Diao Chan and Lu Ji were rescued by Gao Pang.

As a loyal subordinate, it is the responsibility to continue to protect the lord's wife and children; secondly, the unwillingness that was depressed in his heart. Strictly speaking, the defeat of Xiao Guan was not Gao Shun, or the defeat of the entire Lu Bu army. In this regard, Gao Shun, as the commander of the trap camp, had a desire for revenge for his direct opponent, the Xiahou brothers. Although this is not the main reason, as a soldier, it is also a motivation to support him in survival. In the author, Gao Shun is actually a standard soldier.

10. Why should Gao Shun die? This question is the most difficult to answer. The articles of the Three Kingdoms online often kill many enemies, and almost no one dares to let their own people die. I wonder if you have ever thought that letting a soldier die in battle is actually a very dignified and glorious thing for him. Now it is the 60th anniversary of the War of Resistance Against Japan. Shouldn’t we respect them as a large number of martyrs who sacrificed their lives to defend the motherland? (I personally admire General Zhang Zizhong, who died most, and I have paid tribute to him in silence!)

Okay, I'm unknowingly spreading a lot of things, and I don't know if it's right, even if I'll share it with you! Let me add that, don't you just come to see Xin San, just like his uniqueness and uniqueness? If Xin San is the same as a whole lot of other books, then it's not Xin San. If Xin San is to cater to YY's taste, those readers who really like the story of the Three Kingdoms will definitely be disappointed, which is what I don't want to see.

Jingjingliang
Chapter completed!