"I think we should be cautious when judging no responsibility, and the trial result should at least comply with the principle of fair responsibility."

"When the principle of fair responsibility was first established, the purpose was to reflect the law's care for the party that was damaged by interests. If you have no responsibility, you will be too cruel to the plaintiff."

"I still have the same view. For today's society, it is probably even harder to curb the indifference of human nature!"

"The principle of fair responsibility has always been controversial. I believe that the law is not a mix of scattered people. Its purpose is to assist the better development of the country and society..."

“…”

The seven people were very cautious about the results of this judgment.

From the eucalyptus itself...

It gradually involves advocating the value of society, changing the atmosphere, and the "principle of fair responsibility".

There has always been an important principle in civil compensation.

That is the principle of fair responsibility.

Regardless of whether you are wrong or not, as long as one party suffers a significant loss...

The other party must provide corresponding civil compensation to demonstrate the law's protection and care for the weak.

actually.

When the law was first signed, it was to ensure fairness, prevent the weak from being exploited, and protect the rights of the weak.

But this rule has always been controversial in the legal community.

There are different views.

For example, if you drive normally, you have a car accident, and the other party hits you but dies...

I was obviously hit and had no responsibility.

A considerable civil compensation is also required!

"Everyone, everyone should have seen the changes in the current social atmosphere over the past few decades. Do you think... it is important to take into account fairness, or is it an urgent matter?"

"Those who carry firewood for everyone should not let them freeze to death in the wind and snow!"

Zhou Quanmin slowly raised his head and glanced at the other six people.

A question was issued.

In the final statement.

Qin Mu listed fifteen years of precedents.

Very representative.

The incident that happened back then caused a sensation.

Countless people compiled it into jokes, before helping others, their families run a BMW, and after helping others...

Only one broken bicycle is left.

Although it was a joke, it was enough to reflect the bad influence of that matter.

Help others, since you have to worry about whether you will be accused, you will be sentenced to pay for your money...

Then I just don't help.

I saw someone hit by a car, slumped on the side of the road, watching indifferently, and posting photos on WeChat Moments everywhere.

Anyway, it is also legally stipulated...

As long as it is not a collision, it has nothing to do with you.

Even if you look at the person hit and die of blood on the spot, you don’t have to bear any responsibility.

Instead...

He rescued the person, sent him to the hospital, helped pay the medical expenses, and his family also asked for compensation!

The case that Yuan Cuilian sued is also extremely special.

No matter how much compensation is made, even if it is a penny of compensation...

It is equivalent to telling the world that the act of bravery is wrong!

...

One hour later.

The Second Criminal Trial Court.

Zhou Quanmin returned to his seat with the collegial panel.

"Everyone stands up!"

The bailiff spoke in a deep voice.

The plaintiff's bench, the defendant's bench, and the audience stood up together.

Staring at the collegial panel ahead.

Everyone is looking forward to the outcome of the judgment.

I felt a little nervous.

Yuan Cuilian hopes that the court can rule that Qin Mu and others should bear the responsibilities they deserve and provide corresponding civil compensation.

Liang Chengbin, Bai Xuelan and Hua Li were a little nervous.

I don't know how the court will make a judgment.

Especially Liang Chengbin.

His family is not in good condition. He has saved more than 100,000 yuan in savings over the years and worked day and night.

But that was to read to my son.

If you really want to lose money...

That was a little worse.

As for bravery?

He will never take a look at this in the future!

And in the auditorium.

When it came to the most exciting part, all the elderly lost their sleepiness.

He widened his old eyes.

Waiting excitedly for the verdict to appear.

This court session...

The trial lasted nearly eight hours.

From morning to afternoon, the result was finally coming.

"winter--"

Zhou Quanmin took a deep breath and beat the solemn gavel.

A judgment was drawn.

It was announced: "Today, our court formed a collegial panel in accordance with the law to conduct a trial of Qin Mu and others' pursuit and death. Both the plaintiff and the defendant have appeared in court to participate in the lawsuit, and the trial has ended."

"The plaintiff Yuan Cuilian sued Qin Mu, Liang Chengbin, Bai Xuelan and Huali for the death of four people who pursued and fled. The incident was caused by the fact that on the 27th of last month, Bai Xuelan was walking normally and was snatched a gold necklace by Xia Yuan on the street."

"After trial, the facts have been found out. Qin Mu and Liang Chengbin heard the shouts and bravely acted, chasing Xia Yuan, with surveillance along the way, witnesses..."

After briefly stating the facts.

Zhou Quanmin looked at the people in the court and said in a deep voice: "This court believes that Xia Yuan's behavior of crossing the road during the process of being chased violated the Traffic Safety Law. His dangerous behavior was created by himself and was a dangerous self-inducing behavior, and had no necessary causal relationship with others."

"According to Article 233 of the Criminal Law, the crime of negligent death must be caused by negligent acts, and this situation does not exist in this case. The pursuers of Qin Mu, Liang Chengbin and Bai Xuelan will not bear criminal responsibility."

"Huali was driving normally and encountered a traffic accident. According to the traffic police department's responsibilities, he did not bear the main responsibility and did not constitute a traffic accident."

"In accordance with Article 183 and Article 184 of the Civil Code, those who act bravely and act bravely shall not bear civil liability except for major negligence."

"After trial, the facts were clear and the evidence was clear. This court believes that Qin Mu and Liang Chengbin did not perform excessive acts such as intimidation or threats in the process of performing their bravery. Xia Yuan's death was a dangerous self-inflicted situation and there was no major negligence."

"In accordance with Article 233 of the Criminal Law, Article 183 and Article 184 of the Civil Code, the judgment is now announced as follows:

All the plaintiff Yuan Cuilian's claim was rejected. The pursuit of Qin Mu, Liang Chengbin and Bai Xuelan did not constitute a legal causal relationship and did not require criminal liability; there was no serious negligence and no civil liability was required.

In addition, Qin Mu and Liang Chengbin's pursuit is not illegal and is a brave act. They should be supported and encouraged. The relevant directly affiliated departments should give affirmation and rewards materially and spiritually.

In addition, Article 263 of the Criminal Law: Xia Yuan was guilty of robbery, and the facts were determined clearly and the evidence was sufficient. He did not need to bear criminal responsibility because of his death. He ordered his family to compensate Bai Xuelan for mental losses, loss of work, nutritional expenses, etc., totaling 13,000 yuan.

Huali drove a motor vehicle, causing Xia Yuan's death, and needed to pay civil compensation of 8,000 yuan to his family."

"If you do not obey this judgment, you may file a retrial with this court or appeal to the higher court within ten days from the date of issuance of the judgment."

A full ten minutes.

Zhou Quanmin announced the verdict for this case and exhaled a long breath.
To be continued...